Mary Poppins ~ Let's Go Fly A Paradigm
The Wealth We Can't Bank
I believe art has the power to change us.
Not only to entertain us, move us to tears or give us something beautiful to remember, but to fundamentally alter how we perceive ourselves, one another and even God.
I've experienced this personally. I've walked into a movie theater holding certain assumptions about life and walked out questioning things I hadn't even realized I believed.
And sometimes the most profound lessons arrive in the most unexpected packages.
Like Spider-Man for instance.
Years ago, while watching The Amazing Spider-Man in the theater, I found myself cynically dismissing a scene in which construction workers coordinated their cranes to help an injured Spider-Man cross the city.
Oh, please. This is Hollywood. People wouldn't actually do that.
I remember thinking that most people were far too absorbed in their own lives to care enough to help a stranger.
What followed felt like a gentle correction from God.
Grounded in my belief in our premortal existence, I was reminded that every soul who entered this mortal life had once chosen Christ's plan over Lucifer's. Why was I so quick to assume that the people around me were fundamentally unwilling to do good?
If I believed humanity carried the seeds of divinity, why was I so ready to expect selfishness rather than goodness?
My cynicism had become a form of unrighteous judgment. I was presuming to know the hearts of people I had never met, and somehow imagining that my own willingness to help was more exceptional than theirs.
Ouch.
A superhero movie had exposed something in my own heart that needed healing.
That experience has stayed with me. It taught me that stories can do more than communicate the ideas their creators intended. They can become occasions for personal revelation, self-examination and spiritual growth.
Of course, art can also communicate falsehood, glorify destructive behavior or manipulate our emotions. That's why discernment matters. I'm not suggesting we should accept every message a filmmaker presents simply because it moves us.
But when we approach art with a willingness to be taught, testing what we encounter against principles we believe to be true, remarkable things can happen.
With that in mind, my daughter and I decided to begin watching a musical each week, discussing it and recording whatever insights emerged.
Our first selection was Mary Poppins.
The project immediately encountered a scheduling complication known as grandchildren.
They were staying with us, and sustained philosophical contemplation proved somewhat difficult amid the demands of actual children. There is something wonderfully ironic about attempting to extract profound lessons from a magical nanny while real children are dismantling your concentration.
Nevertheless, between interruptions, we managed to watch and analyze the movie.
I discovered that the film I remembered from childhood had far more to say than I'd realized.
Beneath the dancing penguins, floating tea parties and a handbag that violates every known law of physics lies a surprisingly serious examination of wealth, identity, responsibility and love.
The Illusion of Wealth
By every conventional Edwardian measure, George Banks is a successful man.
He holds a respectable position at the bank, lives in a beautiful home with domestic servants and maintains a meticulously ordered household.
He has a wife, two children, and the financial security to provide for them.
Yet he may be the most impoverished character in the entire film.
His poverty isn't financial. It's relational and spiritual.
George has confused his position with his identity, and his responsibilities with their purpose.
He sees himself primarily as a banker, a provider and the unquestioned authority of Number 17 Cherry Tree Lane. His household operates according to a rigid schedule, and he takes considerable pride in keeping everything and everyone in their proper place.
Unfortunately, he seems to regard his family as something to manage rather than people to know and cherish.
And therein lies the tragedy.
George already possesses extraordinary wealth.
His children adore him and long for his attention. His wife loves him. His home contains the possibility of genuine happiness and connection.
He simply doesn't recognize the value of what he has.
He's so preoccupied with maintaining the appearance of a successful life that he has forgotten to actually live one.
An Advertisement That Reaches Heaven
Early in the story, Mr Banks advertises for a nanny who will uphold his strict expectations.
Jane and Michael have very different ideas.
They write their own advertisement asking for someone kind, playful, understanding and willing to enter their world.
George dismisses their wishes, tears the paper to pieces, and throws it into the fireplace.
But the children's words mysteriously rise up the chimney and find their way to Mary Poppins.
I found this deeply symbolic.
The person holding authority in the household has rejected the children's petition, yet their request is heard anyway.
It reminds me of a prayer reaching heaven even when earthly authority has dismissed it.
Mary arrives in response to those with the least power in the household, but she also comes to help someone who doesn't realize he needs saving.
George believes he's hiring a nanny to correct his children.
He has absolutely no idea what's coming. 😂
I particularly enjoyed the employment interview.
Mary walks into George's office and proceeds to take complete control of the conversation while somehow allowing him to believe he's still in charge.
She establishes her own terms, decides what qualifications matter and concludes the interview when she's satisfied.
George is thoroughly railroaded, and he barely seems to notice.
I couldn't help laughing because I've occasionally felt that way in my own interactions with Jesus.
There I am, confidently making plans and explaining how things ought to work, only to discover later that the Lord has been directing matters in ways I never anticipated.
And somehow, I thought it was all my idea.
I don't see Mary Poppins as a perfect allegorical representation of Christ. Her personality and behavior don't translate neatly into that comparison.
But she certainly functions as a Christlike agent of restoration.
She enters a troubled household, recognizes needs hidden beneath the surface then sets about restoring what has become disordered.
And there's something especially interesting about her character.
Mary refuses to be defined by anyone else's expectations.
George and Winifred are both trapped in roles they believe they must fulfill. Mary, by contrast, seems entirely unconcerned with social approval.
She knows who she is.
She knows what she's there to accomplish.
She doesn't need George's permission to be herself, nor does she rebel against him simply for the pleasure of being contrary.
She operates according to a different understanding of authority and purpose.
True freedom isn't necessarily the absence of responsibility.
Sometimes it's knowing your purpose so clearly that other people's expectations no longer determine your identity.
The Medicine Is Still Medicine
One of the things I appreciated most about Mary was that she didn't rescue the children from responsibility.
They still had to clean the nursery.
They still had to take their medicine.
They still had to learn how to behave.
She introduced the possibility that responsibility and joy were not mutually exclusive.
The medicine remained medicine. It just happened to be flavored.
A Confession About Magical Housekeeping
I have to confess that the magical nursery cleaning scene held a very particular appeal for me as a child.
I used to daydream about possessing Mary Poppin's powers. I was also a tremendous admirer of Samantha from Bewitched, whose ability to accomplish practically anything with a wiggle of her nose seemed like an exceptionally sensible arrangement.
And apparently, I never entirely outgrew the fantasy.
While watching the movie with my family, I suddenly remembered being a young mother with my two oldest boys, sitting on the couch and deliberately imagining that I possessed those same extraordinary abilities.
In my mind, the house was cleaning itself, dinner was preparing itself and every household responsibility was being handled beautifully while I remained comfortably seated.
Unfortunately, my actual house seemed completely unimpressed by the performance.
I've long had a tendency toward immersive daydreaming, and I recognize that it can sometimes become an unhealthy form of avoidance for me. But remembering this particular fantasy made me laugh, especially when I considered what Mary Poppins was actually teaching.
Mary was using the magic to transform the experience of doing the work.
There's a difference.
And I wonder how often I've approached life's responsibilities with that same longing for a magical escape when the more meaningful transformation might involve learning to experience those responsibilities differently.
We often approach obedience and spiritual duty as though solemnity demands misery. But as our relationship with God deepens, obedience can shift from enduring demands to joyfully participating in something good.
The nursery still needs cleaning. The medicine still needs swallowing.
Apparently, I was so busy imagining myself cleaning the house from the couch that I missed the lesson entirely.
Who Is Actually Rich?
As I watched the film, I began noticing that nearly every major character seemed to embody a different understanding of wealth.
George Banks possesses financial security but lacks perspective and connection.
The Bird Woman possesses almost nothing materially, yet embodies generosity and compassion.
The chimney sweeps occupy one of society's lowest economic positions, but they seem to enjoy an abundance of community, freedom and joy.
Bert has no impressive social standing, yet possesses imagination, contentment and an extraordinary ability to enrich the lives of others.
The children have almost no authority, but they recognize values the adults have forgotten.
And Mary Poppins herself appears entirely unconcerned with conventional measures of status.
The film repeatedly turns our expectations upside down.
Those who appear wealthy are sometimes impoverished.
Those who appear impoverished are sometimes extraordinarily rich.
The Bird Woman: Wealth That Cannot Be Deposited
For me, the emotional and moral center of Mary Poppins is the Bird Woman.
Sitting on the steps of St. Paul's Cathedral, she offers small bags of breadcrumbs for tuppence.
She has no apparent influence, no impressive possessions, no important position in society.
Yet her presence carries a moral weight that dwarfs the imposing financial institution nearby.
Her wealth is found in what she gives, not what she accumulates.
And Mary's invitation to the children is essentially an invitation to notice someone the world might overlook.
The Bird Woman isn't asking the children to solve every problem of poverty or suffering.
She's offering them an opportunity to participate in a small act of compassion.
At the bank, Michael's tuppence is treated as an opportunity to participate in the machinery of financial growth.
The bankers see investment, accumulation and the promise of future wealth.
Michael sees the possibility of feeding the birds.
But there's another dimension to this scene that touched me deeply.
Michael wants to feed the birds, yet he also desperately wants to please his father.
He wants to do something kind, but he wants his father's approval too.
And George eventually begins to recognize the emotional cost of demanding that his son surrender something meaningful to him in order to satisfy his father's expectations.
The son inadvertently teaches his father the value of love.
I don't think the film is condemning saving, investment or financial responsibility. Money can accomplish tremendous good.
The problem arises when accumulation becomes an end in itself.
A tuppence invested might eventually produce more money.
A tuppence given in compassion can produce something no bank ledger can measure.
And that brings us to a more important question than whether we should save or give:
Do we remember what money is for?
The Lowest People With the Highest View
One of my more amusing discoveries during this viewing came from a scene I remember finding rather boring as a child.
The chimney sweeps.
I remember thinking that they just kept dancing. And dancing. And dancing.
Surely this was the longest dance in cinematic history!
But as an adult, I found myself paying attention to something I had completely overlooked.
Bert speaks appreciatively of the magnificent view available from the rooftops.
And I was struck by the irony.
Here were people occupying one of the lowest positions in the social hierarchy, performing dirty and difficult work, yet enjoying one of the most breathtaking perspectives in London.
And what made that observation especially meaningful was that they recognized the blessing.
It wasn't lost on them.
They weren't simply enduring their circumstances while dreaming of something better. They were capable of recognizing beauty and abundance within the lives they already possessed.
Meanwhile, George Banks spent his days enclosed within the respectable walls of his bank, surrounded by wealth and prestige, yet unable to see much beyond his own narrow priorities.
The chimney sweeps have little status, but they possess community.
They have demanding work, but they possess joy.
They own relatively little, but they experience freedom of spirit.
And their work, the very thing that places them near the bottom of society, gives them access to a perspective others may never enjoy.
Of course, poverty isn't inherently virtuous, and hardship doesn't automatically produce wisdom.
But our circumstances and social standing are remarkably poor indicators of what we're capable of seeing and appreciating.
Sometimes the very experiences we consider undesirable can offer us perspectives we would never have acquired otherwise.
I also found myself thinking about the soot.
The chimney sweeps don't have to become clean, polished and respectable before they're allowed to experience beauty.
They're standing there covered in the evidence of their labor, looking out over a magnificent city.
And they know how fortunate they are to see it.
Bert: The Wealth of a Free Spirit
Bert may be one of the most spiritually prosperous characters in the film.
He's a street artist, musician, chimney sweep and whatever else the day happens to require.
I'm not entirely sure what his employment situation looks like, but he certainly seems to have diversified his portfolio.
Just not in a way the bankers would appreciate.
Yet Bert doesn't measure himself by his occupation or social position.
He sees possibilities everywhere.
A pavement becomes a work of art.
A rooftop becomes a ballroom.
An ordinary day becomes an opportunity for wonder.
And his wealth isn't limited to his own enjoyment.
He gives freely of his attention, encouragement, humor, and understanding.
I've wondered whether Bert might represent something like a faithful disciple.
If Mary is understood as a Christlike figure, Bert seems to recognize and participate in her restorative work.
He doesn't possess her extraordinary abilities, but he helps others see what she's trying to accomplish.
His conversation with George is particularly important.
Bert understands that childhood is fleeting, that the children won't remain young forever and that a father's opportunities to know them can't simply be postponed until his professional responsibilities become less demanding.
He speaks a truth George desperately needs to hear.
And the most significant thing about Bert may be that he doesn't need extraordinary powers to accomplish extraordinary good.
He simply recognizes what matters and helps someone else recognize it too.
Winifred Banks and the Roles We Play
Winifred Banks presents another kind of struggle.
She's passionate about women's suffrage, advocating for women's voices and independence in public life.
Yet within her own home, she often seems anxious to fulfill George's expectations of a proper wife.
There's a fascinating contradiction here.
She champions women's independence while struggling to exercise her own.
George has defined himself through his position at the bank.
Winifred seems caught between her public convictions and her desire to fit the respectable domestic role expected of her.
Both are living according to scripts.
George must be the successful banker.
Winifred must be the proper wife.
And somewhere within those roles, their relationships have suffered.
But Winifred possesses something George has overlooked.
When his professional standing collapses, she doesn't abandon him.
She continues to love him.
At the very moment George believes he has lost his worth, Winifred demonstrates that his value to her was never dependent upon his position at the bank.
I find that especially touching.
And I don't think we should overlook the possibility that her loyalty isn't something she suddenly acquires. It may be a virtue she possessed all along, even while struggling with the expectations imposed upon her.
Her character raises an important question.
Can we become so consumed with fulfilling the expectations attached to our roles that we lose sight of who we actually are?
And can we pursue worthy causes while neglecting other equally worthy responsibilities?
Winifred's political convictions are not inherently at odds with her marriage or motherhood.
The challenge is learning how to live as a whole person rather than dividing herself among competing expectations.
True partnership shouldn't require either spouse to surrender their identity.
It should allow both to bring their whole selves into the relationship.
The Joy That Makes Us Rise
One of the film's most delightful scenes involves Uncle Albert and the extraordinary effects of laughter.
Their joy literally lifts them off the ground.
I love that image.
Laughter can make us feel lighter. Joy can lift our spirits, change our perspective and temporarily free us from the weight of ordinary concerns.
But I also found myself thinking about the importance of remaining grounded.
The characters can't remain suspended near the ceiling forever.
Eventually, they have to return to earth.
And there's a lesson in that too.
Joy isn't necessarily meant to remove us permanently from our responsibilities.
It can renew us so that we return to them with a different perspective.
We need both the ability to rise above our burdens and the willingness to return to the work of living.
I think Mary understands this perfectly.
She brings extraordinary joy into the children's lives, but she never allows the extraordinary to become an excuse for abandoning the ordinary.
The children still have to go home.
The nursery still needs cleaning.
The medicine still needs swallowing.
And life, with all its responsibilities, continues.
When Everything Falls Apart
George's transformation reaches its turning point when the identity he has constructed around his career begins to collapse.
He faces disgrace at the bank.
The respectability he has worked so hard to preserve appears to be slipping away.
And with it goes his understanding of himself.
But what initially looks like ruin becomes the beginning of liberation.
George discovers that losing his professional standing doesn't mean losing everything.
In fact, it exposes the reality that he has been overlooking what matters most.
His wife still loves him.
His children still need him.
His family is still there.
The things he feared losing were never the only things worth possessing.
And when George begins to understand this, something remarkable happens.
He laughs.
The man who once measured every moment according to duty and efficiency discovers joy.
The rigid clockwork machinery of his identity finally begins to loosen.
He hasn't ceased to be responsible.
He's begun to understand the purpose of responsibility.
And significantly, the film doesn't leave him permanently ruined financially. His relationship with the bank is restored.
The lesson isn't that George must choose between financial security and family.
It's that he must learn which deserves his deepest devotion.
The Kite: What Is Broken Can Be Repaired
The ending of Mary Poppins may be my favorite part of the entire film.
George Banks repairs the children's kite.
He doesn't go out and purchase a new one.
He doesn't delegate the task to someone else.
He personally participates in repairing what was broken.
And then the family goes out together to fly it.
The symbolism is almost impossibly beautiful.
At the beginning of the film, the kite represents the children's longing for their father's attention.
By the end, it becomes an instrument of reconciliation.
George hasn't purchased his children's happiness.
He has given them himself.
And the kite's restoration mirrors the restoration of the family.
The kite wasn't replaced.
The family wasn't replaced.
George wasn't replaced by a different father.
But there's something else happening in that final scene.
The entire family steps outside the rigid roles that have confined them.
George is no longer merely the stern banker.
Winifred is no longer simply performing the expectations of a respectable wife.
The children are no longer problems to be managed.
For a moment, they're simply a family.
Together.
Participating in something joyful, imaginative and entirely unproductive by George's former standards.
And yet it may be the most valuable thing we've seen them do.
The final song invites them to fly a kite "up to the highest height."
I can't help connecting that image to the chimney sweeps.
Earlier, the humblest people in London enjoyed the highest perspective.
Now George and his family are looking upward too.
They've finally begun to see what Bert and the chimney sweeps understood all along.
When the Work Is Finished
And then Mary Poppins leaves.
She doesn't stay to receive praise.
She doesn't insist that the family acknowledge everything she's accomplished.
She doesn't make herself indispensable.
Her work is finished because the family has begun to find its way back to one another.
I find that profoundly moving.
There's a kind of love that seeks to become permanently necessary, and another kind that works toward the restoration and independence of those it serves.
Mary seems to embody the second.
She doesn't replace the children's parents.
She helps restore them.
And I think that's one reason I find her character so suggestive of divine intervention.
She enters the story in response to an overlooked petition, works in ways that defy the household's expectations then departs when her purpose has been accomplished.
She never allows herself to be confined by the roles others attempt to assign her.
Yet her freedom isn't aimlessness.
She knows exactly what she's there to do.
The Wealth We Cannot Bank
When I was a child, Mary Poppins was a movie about magic.
A woman who could fly.
A handbag that held an impossible amount of things.
A tea party on the ceiling.
A fantastic world inside a chalk drawing.
And chimney sweeps who danced for an eternity.
Watching it now, I see something different.
I see a story about people who have forgotten how to recognize their own blessings.
A father who mistakes financial standing for personal worth.
A mother struggling beneath competing expectations.
Children who understand the importance of love but lack the authority to make themselves heard.
A Bird Woman whose generosity reveals the limitations of material wealth.
Chimney sweeps who possess almost nothing yet recognize the magnificent view available to them.
And a mysterious nanny who enters their lives to restore the true meaning of responsibility.
The deepest lesson may be that we can spend our lives acquiring the things we believe will make us wealthy while neglecting the very things that make life rich.
Compassion.
Friendship.
Joy.
Imagination.
Connection.
And the ability to recognize beauty in places we never expected to find it.
George Banks didn't need a different family, a larger house, or a more impressive position.
He needed to see what was already in front of him.
And that's what the best art can do for us.
It doesn't always reveal something new.
Sometimes it simply helps us recognize what we've been looking at all along without truly seeing.
As the Banks family walks out together to fly their repaired kite, the film leaves us with an image of freedom that has nothing to do with escaping responsibility.
They are free because they've finally remembered what their responsibilities were meant to serve.
And somewhere behind them, Mary Poppins departs.
Her work is finished.
Comments
Post a Comment